Reviewer Loop
Draft → critique → revise (looped until approved) → publish. A repeatable critique-and-revise pattern with explicit branching.
Steps
Entry step: draft. Each step names the specialist role it wants; the full working prompt is expandable.
- Draftwriterentry
Produce the first cut of the requested artifact and make the review target explicit.
Show working prompt
Create the first complete draft of the requested artifact. Before writing, identify the deliverable path, audience, and 4-6 acceptance criteria in task notes. Then write the draft with the appropriate file-writing tool. Do not ask for critique until a real draft exists. When the draft is written, add a short task note naming the path and the criteria it is intended to satisfy, then call `advance_task_step({ ref, stepId: "draft", next: "evaluate" })`. - Critiquereviewer
Review the draft against the criteria and route either to revision or publish.
Show working prompt
Act as the reviewer. Read the deliverable and the acceptance criteria from task notes. Write a concrete critique to task notes with PASS/FAIL for each criterion and no vague style advice. If every criterion passes, call `advance_task_step({ ref, stepId: "evaluate", next: "publish" })`; publish is the finish route. If any criterion fails, write the specific gaps and call `advance_task_step({ ref, stepId: "evaluate", next: "revise" })`. Never route to publish or finish while a criterion is unmet. - Revisewriter
Address the named critique without redesigning unrelated parts.
Show working prompt
Revise the deliverable to address exactly the critique in task notes. Preserve criteria that already passed. Make a real file edit; a prose promise is not enough. After editing, write a short task note listing which critique items were fixed and call `advance_task_step({ ref, stepId: "revise", next: "evaluate" })` so the reviewer can check the revision. - Publishwriter
Stamp the final summary after reviewer approval.
Show working prompt
The reviewer approved the artifact. Write a one-paragraph DONE summary to task notes naming the final deliverable path and the acceptance criteria that passed. Then report DONE.
Triggers
Phrases that suggest this craftbook to a crew.
- draft critique revise
- reviewer loop
- critique and revise
- polish this draft
Source
View this craftbook on GitHub · MIT license